Friday, August 1, 2014

You Should Get Out More

One of the common errors I keep ranting about is companies – and particularly senior management teams of companies – who have no idea who their customers, employees, suppliers or other stakeholders actually are. This is what gets you silly statements about employees wanting the “prestige” of a promotion that offers more work and longer hours for effectively less money (exempt jobs that pay less than hourly jobs when you include overtime), and tone-deaf comments about people who should just buy what you’re offering and quit asking for what they want. Most recently, it would appear, it has resulted in the CEO of Frontier Communications stating that her customers in Portland are too dumb to understand why they don’t need a broadband speed 80 to 160 times faster than anything they have now…

I don’t know if you’ve been following the development of Google Fiber, but you can read more about it here if you want to. In many parts of the country, including Central Michigan, the prevailing Internet speeds can run as low as 1bps or lower, and even advanced systems rarely exceed 30 mbps. With a limited number of companies competing in each market there isn’t usually any need to upgrade either the systems or the service provided; after all, if your competition is offering a top speed of 10mbps and you can offer 12, you’re 20% faster. There are satellite-based systems that can do better, but most of them are relatively expensive, and you are still limited in where you can get them…

Google is building its own fiber-optic delivery systems and offering to provide speeds in excess of 1,000 mbps in an increasing number of medium-sized cities around the US, which does sound like it would be an advantage over a system operating at 1% or less of that speed. Moreover, Frontier Communications currently has a monopoly on broadband service in Portland, and has therefore never had to worry about the competition in terms of download speed or anything else. But as much as it sounds like Frontier is trying to confuse the issue while running scared, they do have a point: Currently, there is no service or system in general use that requires a speed of 1,000 mbps. In fact, there’s some question as to whether anyone has hardware that could make use of such access even if it existed. And it is also true that Frontier is offering basic service at less than half of what Google Fiber will cost. Unfortunately, both of those contentions are rather missing the point…

First of all, consider that anyone whose broadband use is limited to small and occasional downloads isn’t going to care about a higher access speed in the first place, and they’re certainly not going to go to the trouble of changing providers. But the key demographic for Google Fiber is people who do make use of larger downloads or streaming audio/visual services, and not only do they want the fastest access speeds possible, but they’re not going to take kindly to being told that they are too stupid or too technologically inept to understand how fast Internet connections work. In fact, a lot of power users will probably change providers just because they’re been insulted in such a tone-deaf fashion – but that isn’t even the worst of it…

While it might be true that no one could possibly make full use of a 1,000 mbps Internet connection as of today, I won’t take any bets about that being true for long – especially if such download speeds become widely available. Somebody will find something to do with them, and technology-oriented users are likely to want that capability even before they find out what such new services can do. If technology has taught us anything in the last three decades, it’s that the curve is rising faster than we can keep up with it, and the technology that seemed like science fiction only a few years ago will be available in every big-box retailer by Black Friday if not before…

All of these things would be obvious to anyone who was paying attention to the customer demographics involved, the development of the Technology sector over the past few years, the rise of services like Dish Network, Netflix and Hulu, the appearance of the “Cord-Cutter” movement, or the increasing use of home WIFI systems. In fact, all of this should be obvious to anyone who is actually in touch with the world around them, and not just sitting in their Executive Suite and listening to an echo chamber of yes-people telling them what they wanted to hear. If that is the case, I can only suggest that Ms. Wilderotter of Frontier Communications needs to get out more…

No comments: