Showing posts with label Reform. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Reform. Show all posts

Sunday, October 27, 2013

The Ethics of Profit

We were discussing the subject of for-profit colleges the other day when the question came up about whether these enterprises have any functional utility. We’ve all seen the stories about crooked for-profit schools taking advantage of students by charging outrageous tuition fees, encouraging students to take out student loans they have no hope of ever paying back, or even accepting large cohorts of students, collecting non-refundable fees, and then flunking out the entire class for academic deficiency before the end of their first semester. But clearly not all of the companies in this industry are corrupt or fraudulent; many of them operate honestly enough, taking on students who are unable or unwilling to find suitable education in conventional channels and providing useful instruction at a reasonable price. The real question would appear to be not so much why the fraudulent organizations are tolerated, but under what conditions a useful for-profit college can be operated…

What sets for-profit schools apart is that, unlike most other companies, these organizations are attempting to serve the public interest as well as generate revenue for the owners. Much like a for-profit hospital or a for-profit insurance company, these schools are still trying to generate a positive bottom line, but also like these institutions they are serving the need for educational opportunities (on the part of the citizens) and the need for a better-educated workforce (on the part of society). Or, to look at it another way, if a for-profit school is not providing anything of value for its customers (let alone defrauding them or leaving them in debt) it is cheating not only its “students” but all of the rest of us who live in the community where it is allowed to exist. Clearly, then, the ethics of running such an institution are more complicated than those of a company that sells filtered tap water for $40 a bottle or fermented grape juice for $500 a bottle; but what are those ethics specifically?

First, it seems reasonable that any for-profit course of study that enables its graduates to obtain gainful employment – or to upgrade their career prospects, if they are already employed – has some concrete value. Whether it’s a cost-effective method of obtaining that value is up to the student/consumer to decide; a school which costs as much as an Ivy League degree but offers only a $1-per-hour increase in salary probably isn’t worthwhile, though it’s clearly not useless. This suggests than many vocational and technical training programs should be ethically acceptable, and some of the STEM disciplines might be, but most of the Humanities and Liberal Arts subjects should probably be left to traditional institutions…

Second, there’s the issue of predatory lending. For our purposes, lending someone money they can never repay for a useless degree is even more egregious than lending them money they can never repay for a real estate purchase, considering that student loan debts can never be discharged through bankruptcy the way a conventional loan can. Schools obtaining tuition this way are clearly crossing the line. Likewise any school which is deliberately misrepresenting the value of its training programs – advertising the salaries of famous chefs, for example, when all their graduates can look forward to is $14 per hour as a line cook – should be prosecuted under the truth-in-advertising laws and driven out of business. But in both cases, if the costs and benefits are clearly explained up front, and the risks of pursuing such a course are make apparent to the applicants, it’s difficult to say that the companies involved would be committing any crime by accepting payment and providing the classes…

All of which brings me to the real ethical question underlying this issue: how safe a proposition does a given course of study have to be – and how much absolute value does it have to off the student – before we consider it ethically acceptable for a company to offer it to students at a profit to itself? Any number of students will graduate from public and non-profit private schools every year with crushing student loan debt and degrees for which no employment opportunities exist (the so-called “Do you want fries with that?” majors), yet these programs do not generate accusations of fraud or calls for closer regulation. Such events may seem more reprehensible when someone is using those graduates to obtain profit, but there is no appreciable difference in the effect those debts and degrees will have on the lives of the students. So how do we decide what is simply a cost-ineffective educational opportunity and what is a dastardly fraud used to separate would-be students from their money? And who gets to make that decision?

It’s worth thinking about…

Sunday, November 20, 2011

The Ethics of Occupation


I’ve written about the Occupy movement in our regular posts, and I don’t propose to discuss the ethics of their platform itself. If you believe in representative democracy in the first place (and I do) then there’s no question that people should have the right to petition the government for redress of grievances, and whether you agree with the exact points on the “99% Declaration” or not, we can’t really argue that the protesters have the right to raise those points. What I’m asking in this particular case is whether we can support the actual method of protest they’re using. There’s a great history of sit-ins and public demonstrations, not just in this country, but in the world generally; it’s hard to argue that such tactics have led to actual change in the world. However, as we’ve frequently noted, it’s a new world – and this particular protest has taken on some new twists as well…

Consider, for example, that most of the points the protesters are raising are directed at our Federal government, not at any of the companies or entities they are actually camping out around. City and State governments can’t change whether members of Congress have term limits imposed on them, for example, and no one on Wall Street can overturn the Citizen’s United case (which granted corporations the right to protected speech, including campaign donations) even assuming that it wouldn’t be silly for them to want to do so in the first place. From a purely functional standpoint, it’s difficult to see how shutting down the Port of Oakland or camping in a park at the end of Wall Street will impact the creation of Federal law; such actions may communicate the anger and disgust the protesters are feeling, but the people they’re inconveniencing are mainly longshoremen and street vendors – not exactly members of the 1%. And the Occupy Washington group was initially so small that the right-wing opposition started using those numbers to mock the movement as a whole…

Then there’s the “collateral damage” aspect of these tactics. In Oakland we saw the emergence of disruptive and criminal elements, which turned a peaceful protest into a riot and gave the local authorities the justification they needed for attacking unarmed people with clubs and chemical agents. Things haven’t gone as far into the weeds anywhere else, but most of the Occupy encampments have had problems with thefts, local criminals using them for cover, and some of our more reprehensible law enforcement personnel using the protests as an excuse to beat up innocent people. There have also been reports of the camps themselves (and the police lines around them) interfering with local businesses, which is definitely not impacting any giant corporations, but might be harming local people who are just trying to get to work, do their jobs, or make a living. And while all of these things may ultimately be the fault of corrupt, violent or stupid local officials, there’s not much question that none of it would be happening if the protesters had chosen a different set of tactics…

Members of the movement would probably tell you that if their goals are achieved the result will be a better world for everyone, and that the occasional inconvenience or loss they’re causing will be repaid a thousand times over by a better economy, a better system of government and a better life. And for all you and I know, they might be correct – but that’s still too close to an “ends justify the means” argument for me to be comfortable with it. So I feel compelled to ask: given the obvious difficulties with this method of protest and the possible consequences to people who have nothing to do with the injustices being protested in the first place, is the occupation of Wall Street (or anywhere else) really an ethical response to the situation? Can we really dismiss the concerns of everyone who opposes these protests as merely part of the problem, or should we extend those people the same right to be heard that the protesters are demanding for themselves? And perhaps most important of all, who gets to decide?

It’s worth thinking about…

Monday, August 29, 2011

Radical Change

I’ve been reading some of Steve Denning’s columns on the Forbes website recently, and it struck me that my reaction to his comments on the need for radical change may be worth looking at more closely. In many ways, I am that particular everyman that business writers talk about when they describe the behavior of “management types” – a generic MBA with 20+ years in corporate life who has never made it more than three layers up into any hierarchy. However, starting three years ago, I also became a generic business educator – almost exactly average for my department, and only slightly higher than that for the instructors who teach my subject, which is management strategy and strategic management. It’s true that my field experience as a manager crosses a number of different sectors (retail, wholesale, energy, communications, service, consulting and education); it’s also true that my institution (Michigan State) is considered one of the top business schools in the country (even if it collectively doesn’t appear to think much of me). Be that as it may, I’m still right in the center of the demographic which Mr. Denning is speaking of and to – and I have some issues with his conclusions…

Let me be clear, up front, that I would not care to directly contradict so learned a scholar, or one of such experience. Mr. Denning has published six books on the subject of management reform, served as a Director of the World Bank and as a Visiting Fellow at Oxford, and worked with both the Smithsonian and the University of Maryland, whereas all I’ve managed to do in academia so far is irritate the faculty at MSU to an entirely unprecedented extent. That said, on reading through some of Mr. Denning’s comments, I can’t help thinking of belled cats, ivory towers, and the difference between my academic experience (remarkable only for the complete lack of respect I have received from my instructors) and my professional experience (in which I was actually quite well regarded). Or to be specific:

First, the exhortation to change focus from making money for the stockholders to delighting the customer is completely correct, as far as it goes, but can’t be accomplished in a traditional company for the very simple reason that the stockholders are the actual owners of the company, and they have contributed (or pooled, depending on your point of view) their capital for the purpose of making money. If the firm is owned by the employees, or operated entirely as a co-op, this might still be possible, but even then it will be tricky for as long as people remain people. This is especially true in the case of those products and services which are considered to be commodities (e.g., for which no product/service differentiation is possible). In a pure low-cost strategy the only way to “delight” a customer is going to be with a lower cost/price structure, which will require lower margins and less benefit to the firm’s owners.

Second, the idea of self-enabling teams can work in professional settings, but becomes less and less practical as we continue down the scale into semi-skilled or unskilled labor; it is also less practical in the case of inexperienced workers or complex task scenarios. I will not weary the reader with the citations that support this contention (it comes up in both Organizational Behavior and Strategy seminars), but the straight answer is that part of the manager’s role has always been direction of the employees, and even workers who can function without direct supervision still need some amount of direction.

Third, the idea that work can be coordinated in ways other than bureaucracy is not new – it’s one of the seminal arguments of Organization Theory, and has been discussed in detail for at least the past sixty or seventy years. No one is going to claim that work can only be controlled through a massive and unresponsive structure, but not all enterprises lend themselves to either short cycles or direct customer feedback.

Which brings me to the real point of this objection: for several years now, I’ve made a point of teaching my students that management is a process, and the key factor is the manager him or her self – in other words, them. The manager’s duty includes making sure that the customer’s needs are met and, wherever possible, exceeded; it includes making sure that his or her people have the resources they need, including room to work without being hounded or micro-managed; and it includes working with the employees in real time, providing continuous direction as well as feedback and control. None of these things demand a traditional – which is to say, hierarchical – structure of management, but saying that these things can not be accomplished through traditional management (or worse yet, that traditional management theory is finished and must be completely ripped out and replaced) is nonsense. In the end, science can make the manager’s job easier; make the objectives easier to understand and the goals easier to achieve; but it can’t replace the practicing manager, and all of the things he or she has learned about the profession of management.

For those of you who didn’t want to wade through that, the TL;DR version is: the key to management is to manage, and for that you need actual managers. Everything else is just a fancy way of drawing up the org charts. I promise that my next post will have less preaching and more snarky humor – but this needed to be said...

Thursday, November 12, 2009

I’d Buy That for a Dollar!

Most of the time I avoid comment on whether the current age is better or worse than the way things were when I was a child; that sort of thing is clearly geezer-talk, and along that path lies madness. Kids today may not actually have things any better or worse than we did; the world grows more complicated every year, but “good” and “bad” are value judgments, and therefore subjective. For every person who sincerely believes that the iPhone is actually the greatest invention since the wheel there is at least one other person who hates everything about cell phones, smart phones, the Internet, or the Information Age itself and wishes we could all go back to manual typewriters, carbon paper and party lines. But I’d be willing to bet that even some of those people would have liked to be able to purchase higher grades in Middle School…

From the pages of the News Observer online comes the story of a middle school in Goldsboro, NC that was having trouble with its school fund raisers. Last years efforts to raise money by selling candy appears to have fallen flat, so this year the school came up with the idea of using class credit to incentivize its pre-teen salespeople in the student body. According to the published account, a $20 donation to the school would have bought the student a 10-point credit on two tests of the student’s choice; enough to make the difference between a “B” and an “A” – or enough to turn a fail grade into a marginal pass. Of course, school officials dispute whether this would be enough to impact a student’s overall grades in a class, and they insist that no student would be allowed to obtain more than 20 points this way, but I’ve been in class with enough grade-grubbers over the years to know (even if the principal apparently doesn’t) how the students would see this…

Now, I don’t want to imply all of the parents and educators who are talking about how this sends the wrong message to the students and teaches the kids that it’s okay to pay for grades are wrong, exactly; most people do learn ethics by watching their parents (or other authority figures) deal with exactly this sort of decision. What needs to be pointed out here is that this is a slippery slope – and this fund-raiser is hardly the first step onto it. Kids today are already facing such inequities as private test preparation for the SAT (or equivalent) that determines who will get into college based on whose parents can afford such services, and private consultants who can help “package” a student’s college applications to similar effect. The college you select will determine your starting position in a great many careers (or your choice of graduate schools), and every college student in the world has services that will offer to provide “sample” term papers targeting them in various media ads. Even the good kids have to be wondering if it wouldn’t be more efficient to just purchase the grades in the first place…

But what I think is the most disturbing thing about this entire story is the origin of the grades-for-cash program: a parent advisory group came up with it, and the school’s principal approved it. If the school district hadn’t stepped in and shut it down, this program might have become a regular feature at Rosewood Middle School, and might even have spread to other schools. Which means that all of the people who have been railing about the degradation of our educational system by parents who think they can buy their child’s way through everything are actually quite right – and it’s later than we thought. Maybe we should start thinking seriously about education reform in this country while we still can…