Showing posts with label Piracy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Piracy. Show all posts

Wednesday, March 19, 2014

Closer to Home

In my last post I described the extraordinary story of a request I received from one of my students, that I give him my blessing to appropriate some of the materials from our class and post them to a supposedly free website that might or might not compensate him for doing so. It may be that the world has changed even more than I realize, but when I was a student I would certainly not have run the risk of being expelled from the University, let alone sued or charged with a criminal offense, in return for a vague possibility of some future compensation. In fact, there is no way I would have risked angering my instructors – not all of whom were as even-tempered as I am – by asking such a question in the first place. But to me, this is only the beginning of the mystery…

Almost as puzzling, as far as I am concerned, is how does this website make any money? It is possible that they don’t actually give out any gift cards (e.g. everyone who “enters” one of their “drawings” is told that he or she didn’t win), but even if their web hosting and bandwidth are also free, how do they make any revenue on this service if the people downloading the class materials aren’t paying anything for them? It is possible to make money by hosting web ads, but people who come to your site looking for class materials for free are not likely to click on ads offering products for sale – and even less likely to make any purchase if they do. It’s also possible that there is a “premium” version of the site, offering even better stolen material (old test questions, perhaps?) in return for modest subscription fees. But this would make it much easier to catch the people running the site if you wanted to charge them with a crime – and much more likely that someone would be motivated to do that…

It is possible that the people behind this site – whoever and wherever they are – are planning to sell the materials to someone else, possibly other college instructors. A colleague of mine once told me that he had gotten a call from a professor at a university somewhere in Southeast Asia who was using his class materials to teach her school’s equivalent of his class, and who wanted to know if he would send her copies of his last few midterm exams so she could use the questions from them. It’s hard to imagine why anyone would be willing to pay for my slides and materials when they could just make their own, or obtain similar resources from colleagues, departmental archives or publishers, all of whom are potentially sources of free teaching materials that do not involve copyright violations. It’s even harder to imagine when you consider that I’d probably make those materials available to anyone who asked politely…

When I was an undergraduate there was a note-taking service available on our campus that sent a professional note-taker to each class and then typed up that person’s notes and printed copies for anybody who wanted to purchase them. Ostensibly intended to give people the chance to focus on the class without needing to stop and take notes, it was more commonly used by students who were not attending the lecture on a given day to find out what had been covered. I don’t know if the professors whose classes were covered by the service were compensated or not, but they clearly knew these notes were being taken, since there was a published list of classes for which printed notes were available posted each week in the Student Union building. And I must admit that I don’t really care if my students take their own notes, copy a classmate’s notes, or purchase them from a service, so long as they actually study those notes at some point. So if the people who are running this website were to make contact with me directly about listing notes for my class, I would certainly discuss it with them…

They’d have to come up with better compensation than a vague chance in a drawing for a gift card that may or may not actually exist, however…

Sunday, March 16, 2014

The Ethics of Piracy

I had considered an Ethics post about DRM following yesterday’s ravings about digital coffee, but there doesn’t appear to be much to talk about; the sellers certainly have the right to offer or restrict functionality on the products they are offering, and the buyers have the option of voting with their feet (and their wallets) and not purchasing products with DRM or any other measure/feature to which they take exception. Either of these positions could be seen as wrong, greedy/stingy, or actively evil, depending on which side of the debate one happens to be on, but there does not appear to be an ethical issue to discuss. By the same token, there doesn’t appear to be much question that somebody who downloads a program, a movie, a song or whatever from a copyrighted work and does not pay for it is committing an actual crime, and can’t really justify that under any ethical grounds, either. It’s only when one or more of those conditions does not apply that things begin to get murky…

Consider, for example, the case of people who are downloading and using any work that is unavailable to them, specifically because it is out of print and neither the original author or the publisher ever intend to make new copies available. Technically, this is still a copyright violation, and can still be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law, or pursued in civil court for uncompensated use. But if there was no chance whatsoever of the author or publisher ever selling another copy, or earning any other revenue from this product, is it still unethical for people to obtain unauthorized copies for their private use? Does our answer change if these unauthorized users will not make any profits of their own from the product? What if there is no alternative product they could have used for this purpose – as in the case of orphaned or obsolete software?

On the one hand, it could be argued that something does not stop being your property just because you aren’t currently using it, and the owners of the copyright could elect to do something with them at some future point. It could also be argued that if the unauthorized users could not pirate this property they would have to purchase something else, which might actually involve giving revenue to the owners or some other deserving person. On the other hand, it could be argued that some users would not have been able to afford to make any purchase; that if they had not been able to access the pirated work their only other choice would have been nothing – in which case there is no way in which their actions could be of harm to anyone. There is also the possibility of future benefit if you do allow them to access the work…

For some years now a number of companies – notably including Baen Books – have been releasing electronic copies of various works in electronic format, generally DRM free, on the principle that people who read free electronic copies of books will then want to acquire hard-copy versions. It’s also common for some publishers to make the first volume of a series – or a very basic version of a software package, to take another common example – available for free, with the understanding that the rest of the material is available for sale at reasonable prices. This appears to have been moderately successful for the publishers, and is believed to drive a lot of the sales for smart phone apps and the like – which really makes you wonder…

Are there conditions under which the unauthorized access of copyrighted material can be of sufficient value to the holder of the copyright in order to ethically (if not legally) justify doing so? Does our answer change if there is no way the legal owner could possibly make any money on the copyright through any legal or authorized channel? What if the unauthorized use later leads to income for the legal owner from some other enterprise; do the ends then justify the means? Or should we just assume that anyone who wants to see their work freely distributed will use some form of Creative Commons license, and respect the ownership rights of anyone using a conventional copyright or patent, even if doing so is ultimately NOT in the owner’s best interest?

It’s worth thinking about…

Monday, January 4, 2010

Too Big to Fail?

Suppose for a moment that your company makes a product that is the most popular of its kind; the most common and most popular brand in the world. There are many government users, but the product is even more popular in the private sector, and export versions are found in literally every country in the world. Your industry is wide open, and there are in fact many competing products, but none are as cheap, few are as reliable, and certainly none are as well known as your flagship product. Given such a position in the market, is there any way your company could possibly fail?

Well, before you answer that question, you might want to check in with a Russian company called OAO Izhmash, manufacturer of the Kalashnikov, better known as the AK-47 assault rifle. Designed by Mikhail Kalashnikov in 1947 (hence the name), the AK-47 is the most common assault weapon on Earth, with an estimated 70 million examples of the type in service around the world. It’s widely considered to be the most reliable and repairable assault rifle ever built, with documented cases of AK-47s being left buried in mud or sand for years at a time, and then being fished out, wiped off, and working perfectly. So what could possibly cause the company that has been making them since 1947 to file for bankruptcy? In a word: piracy…

According to this story in the Globe and Mail, OAO Izhmash has applied for bankruptcy protection this week, largely because the market has been flooded with cheap foreign knock-offs of its premiere product, the AK-47. The Russian army isn’t buying a lot of weapons these days, but the main problem is that some versions of the AK are available for as little as $50, according to the online article. Apparently, Mr. Kalashnikov succeeded a little too well when he designed the weapon to be easy to fabricate…

Now, as you’ve probably guessed, I’m not calling this to your attention because I believe that any of you are going to neglect to patent, trademark or copyright your work as thoroughly as possible. I’m also not going to cry for a Soviet-era arms manufacturer that is now seeing its birds coming home to roost; the company’s treatment of Mr. Kalashnikov (who has never seen a dime of royalties for ANY of his designs) would be enough to make dislike them, and their State-sponsored contracts served them well enough back in the day. I’m telling you about this situation because it demonstrates that however much we may dislike anti-piracy measures, they’re not always the result of a greedy corporation wanting a bigger slice of the pie – and the cost of circumventing them isn’t always limited to having to pay 99 cents on iTunes…

If you’re a manufacturer (of anything; industry isn’t important here) you need to pay attention to knock-off versions of your product, and fight for your market share. You can use legal action when you’re being ripped off outright, but in the case of imitation products you can employ any number of strategies to maintain your market position – high quality and low cost being the two most familiar ones – but you can’t just bury your head in the sand and hope that people will see through the competition. And if you’re a consumer, you need to think very carefully every time you consider buying a knock-off version of a familiar product. Someday the company being knocked off might be your own…