I’m sending this one on ahead to myself (and any of you who are still reading this space), since I don’t think it would be either fair or safe to publish this post while still employed on this job. So for those of you reading along (including me), welcome back to the second week of June, 2008, and the truly bizarre place known as UCLA Extension, or UNEX…
Several weeks ago our Director scheduled a “retreat” for the Senior Staff members, to discuss ideas for a possible reorganization of the department. With our fiscal year ending, and funds being short, the Director decided to hold the retreat on Monday, June 9, 2008 at the Faculty Club facility on UCLA’s campus (that’s yesterday, from the point of view of when this post was being written). Given the number (and nature) of miss-steps that subsequently occurred, I thought this might be a good time to consider management retreats in general, and some of the things to avoid doing on one in particular…
To begin with, the whole project ran afoul of UNEX rules against spending money on food or entertainment for employees. Technically, even though Extension does not receive any taxpayer money, the funds we do get (from fees and tuitions) are still State money, and can’t be spent on these categories. Undaunted, the Senior Staff made plans to “retreat” to the conference room across the hall. The problem here is that getting off-site – or at least getting out of your regular working space – is critical for this sort of conceptual meeting to work in the first place. Otherwise, not only do you lose the sense of occasion (and importance) obtained by being Outside, but you’re much too likely to have people excuse themselves and go work on their usual assignments – which is in fact what happened…
Then there’s the lack of structure and the overabundance of agendas – which I regret to say are quite typical of this type of retreat. Every member of the management team is going to be threatened by different aspects of a reorganization, and each member of the team will have his or her own ideas about what changes should be made. In the case of our department, the Program Directors have been running their own areas of operation as little independent departments for years, and will resist any chance to centralize control or work more collaboratively, while the Program Managers have been used primarily as Administrative Analysts (not managers at all) during this period, and would like to actually have some hand in running things. If the Department’s Director doesn’t set the agenda and take a firm hand in running the discussion, the results will be anarchy – and the complete waste of a work day – before people decide the whole thing is rubbish, tune out, and the excuse themselves to return to work…
Which is, in fact, what appears to have happened…
Compounding matters, at least as far as I’m concerned, is the fact that I wasn’t invited to this “retreat” myself. Now I know some of you are thinking that since I’m leaving this job in three weeks, getting my opinion on the future direction of the department is not important. That’s almost certainly what my boss was thinking when he told me not to attend. But in this case, he was wrong (and so was anyone out there who agreed with him) for two reasons: First, because I am the only member of this department (however ephemeral) with a management degree, and the only one experience in leading this sort of reorganization event; and second, because with me absent and the third Program Manager position currently vacant, that left only one manager to represent the interests of a good 40% of the management team. The manager in question is a good man, and I’m sure he put on a really good show, but there’s no denying the fact that he was outnumbered five to one…
I could go on, but I think you get the point. The whole exercise was a huge waste of time and resources (although fortunately not taxpayer money), and will have to be repeated any number of times before any substantive change happens – if, in fact, any ever does. All things considered, I’d rather be in Winslow…
Showing posts with label Organizing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Organizing. Show all posts
Sunday, July 6, 2008
Tuesday, July 17, 2007
Getting Organized
As you might expect, Organization is very nearly a science in and of itself, encompassing everything from organizational design to how you arrange items on your desk and I don’t intend to try to cover it all in a single blog post. That said, there are a few key concepts I want to call to your attention precisely because they are so little known and poorly understood – even by the people who should know better.
First off, let’s consider idea of organizational design. Clearly, we want to have as few levels or “layers” of management as we can, since management personnel command high salaries but don’t themselves generate revenue. This means having a few managers and as many workers as we can. In a perfect world, we would just have the CEO supervise everyone else, producing a company with only two levels (an extremely “flat” structure, in business school terms). Unfortunately, this is impossible except in very small organizations. There is a limit to the number of subordinates (or subordinate units) a given manager can supervise effectively; in b-school terms this is referred to as Span of Control.
If our people are doing work that requires very little direction (physical labor, like digging ditches, being the most common example) then a single supervisor might be able to control as many as 30 of them; if they are doing complex intellectual tasks (accounting, writing code, consulting, managing a department) then the Span is more likely to be in the 3 to 8 range. This isn’t an easy balance to strike, but it is critical to the long-term success of the organization. If the span is too large, quality will inevitably suffer because the supervisors will be unable to correct mistakes, and efficiency is likely to drop because the supervisors will also have too many subordinates to direct effectively. If the span is too small, the company will lose money paying too many management personnel, and is likely to suffer from micromanagement on the part of the underutilized management personnel.
Also, note that the Span of Control will vary at different levels of the organization. One foreman can probably handle several dozen ditch-diggers, but a manager will have his hands full trying to supervise more than five or six foremen and their crews, and a Director will do very will to control more than three or four work groups.
Then there’s the issue of duplication of effort. Quite often in large organizations you will have multiple departments engaged in the same task, while other activities are completely ignored. During the planning process you will have broken the overall mission of the company down into goals, objectives, and tasks; while getting organized it pays to group those tasks by similarity, so that work groups with the resources to handle multiple similar tasks are assigned to do so, and multiple groups are not assigned to the same things.
Of course, for any of this happen, the management personnel at all levels need to become involved in the process; ultimately, it is just as important for a single team leader to organize his or her people into the optimal configuration as it is for the Chief Operating Officer to make sure his or her divisions are not working at cross-purposes. The only way to be sure that your subordinates (or subordinate units) are operating efficiently, not duplicating effort, and receiving the correct level of supervision is to understand the process and know what needs to be done – and what everyone reporting to you is able to do. If you came in at the entry level and have worked your way up, you probably already understand what the people and groups reporting to you are doing. If not, there’s no time like the present to find out…
First off, let’s consider idea of organizational design. Clearly, we want to have as few levels or “layers” of management as we can, since management personnel command high salaries but don’t themselves generate revenue. This means having a few managers and as many workers as we can. In a perfect world, we would just have the CEO supervise everyone else, producing a company with only two levels (an extremely “flat” structure, in business school terms). Unfortunately, this is impossible except in very small organizations. There is a limit to the number of subordinates (or subordinate units) a given manager can supervise effectively; in b-school terms this is referred to as Span of Control.
If our people are doing work that requires very little direction (physical labor, like digging ditches, being the most common example) then a single supervisor might be able to control as many as 30 of them; if they are doing complex intellectual tasks (accounting, writing code, consulting, managing a department) then the Span is more likely to be in the 3 to 8 range. This isn’t an easy balance to strike, but it is critical to the long-term success of the organization. If the span is too large, quality will inevitably suffer because the supervisors will be unable to correct mistakes, and efficiency is likely to drop because the supervisors will also have too many subordinates to direct effectively. If the span is too small, the company will lose money paying too many management personnel, and is likely to suffer from micromanagement on the part of the underutilized management personnel.
Also, note that the Span of Control will vary at different levels of the organization. One foreman can probably handle several dozen ditch-diggers, but a manager will have his hands full trying to supervise more than five or six foremen and their crews, and a Director will do very will to control more than three or four work groups.
Then there’s the issue of duplication of effort. Quite often in large organizations you will have multiple departments engaged in the same task, while other activities are completely ignored. During the planning process you will have broken the overall mission of the company down into goals, objectives, and tasks; while getting organized it pays to group those tasks by similarity, so that work groups with the resources to handle multiple similar tasks are assigned to do so, and multiple groups are not assigned to the same things.
Of course, for any of this happen, the management personnel at all levels need to become involved in the process; ultimately, it is just as important for a single team leader to organize his or her people into the optimal configuration as it is for the Chief Operating Officer to make sure his or her divisions are not working at cross-purposes. The only way to be sure that your subordinates (or subordinate units) are operating efficiently, not duplicating effort, and receiving the correct level of supervision is to understand the process and know what needs to be done – and what everyone reporting to you is able to do. If you came in at the entry level and have worked your way up, you probably already understand what the people and groups reporting to you are doing. If not, there’s no time like the present to find out…
Wednesday, July 11, 2007
The Manager’s Job
By now I’ve made so many comments about managers doing their jobs (and failing to do so) that some of you are probably wondering what it is that a manager is actually supposed to do. Asking around the office won’t help; your supervisor will probably start going on about making schedules, wrestling with budgets, writing reports, making sure that key operations do not become fouled up, and lot of other specific duties that won’t tell you anything about the science of management. Asking a management professional probably won’t help either; most of us would claim to make the sun rise and the crops grow if we thought anyone would believe us for a moment.
All of this contributes to management science appearing to be much more complex than it really is, and helps to keep the salaries of people trained in it from plummeting any farther than they already have. As a result, too many people are intimidated by the idea of studying management, and wind up either faking it and hoping for the best, or staying out of management positions altogether. The truth, however, is far less grand. The science of management is comprised of four (and only four) main parts: Planning, Organizing, Directing and Controlling.
Planning includes Strategic Planning, Operational Planning, Daily Planning, and a variety of more specialized planning functions. Some companies actually maintain a Strategic Planning (or Forward Planning) department, usually reporting to the President or General Manager, specifically to help the various senior managers keep their plans straight. So if you’ve ever felt that a manager who refuses to plan things out in advance is derelict in his/her duty (as well as incompetent), you are quite correct…
Organizing is probably the least understood of the functions – and consequently, the one most often done incorrectly or ignored altogether. If the Planning function is the means by which we determine what we want to accomplish, then the Organizing function could best be described at the means by which we determine HOW we will accomplish these things. This will mean determining which personnel will perform which functions (organizing the company into departments, workgroups, and teams), how much time and money and other resources will be devoted to each task (the scheduling and budgeting functions), and what processes will be used to insure performance, quality, proper supervision, and so on.
Directing is the function most people associate with active management: telling your subordinates what you want them to do. Managers of a strict and hierarchical nature may see this as “giving orders” while those of a more artistic bent may see it as directing a play or conducting a symphony. Some people are so uncomfortable with this concept that they will give it a less forceful-sounding name (such as “leading” or “coordinating”); true failures may actually refuse to do it, and let the employees just do as they will.
Finally, Controlling is the feedback part of the process, whereby the manager monitors the progress being made toward goals and performance targets, corrects problems, adjusts plans, rewards those exceeding expectations, and brings those who are failing back into line. It is important to note that the Controlling function must be part of the manager’s daily responsibilities; limiting the Controlling functions to annual reviews or the occasional disciplinary action is every bit as incompetent as limiting the Planning function to a few days each year when the budgets and sales targets are formulated.
Of course, any specific manager may also be tasked with additional functions by higher management, and many professionals serving in the manager’s role will also have work of their own to complete. But the manager’s job itself remains the same – and has, in fact, since the first group of people began working on a project together. The only real questions facing the management professional are “Are you performing all four of these functions?” (you’d better be!) and “How do I perform all of these functions?”
Which is a topic for another day…
All of this contributes to management science appearing to be much more complex than it really is, and helps to keep the salaries of people trained in it from plummeting any farther than they already have. As a result, too many people are intimidated by the idea of studying management, and wind up either faking it and hoping for the best, or staying out of management positions altogether. The truth, however, is far less grand. The science of management is comprised of four (and only four) main parts: Planning, Organizing, Directing and Controlling.
Planning includes Strategic Planning, Operational Planning, Daily Planning, and a variety of more specialized planning functions. Some companies actually maintain a Strategic Planning (or Forward Planning) department, usually reporting to the President or General Manager, specifically to help the various senior managers keep their plans straight. So if you’ve ever felt that a manager who refuses to plan things out in advance is derelict in his/her duty (as well as incompetent), you are quite correct…
Organizing is probably the least understood of the functions – and consequently, the one most often done incorrectly or ignored altogether. If the Planning function is the means by which we determine what we want to accomplish, then the Organizing function could best be described at the means by which we determine HOW we will accomplish these things. This will mean determining which personnel will perform which functions (organizing the company into departments, workgroups, and teams), how much time and money and other resources will be devoted to each task (the scheduling and budgeting functions), and what processes will be used to insure performance, quality, proper supervision, and so on.
Directing is the function most people associate with active management: telling your subordinates what you want them to do. Managers of a strict and hierarchical nature may see this as “giving orders” while those of a more artistic bent may see it as directing a play or conducting a symphony. Some people are so uncomfortable with this concept that they will give it a less forceful-sounding name (such as “leading” or “coordinating”); true failures may actually refuse to do it, and let the employees just do as they will.
Finally, Controlling is the feedback part of the process, whereby the manager monitors the progress being made toward goals and performance targets, corrects problems, adjusts plans, rewards those exceeding expectations, and brings those who are failing back into line. It is important to note that the Controlling function must be part of the manager’s daily responsibilities; limiting the Controlling functions to annual reviews or the occasional disciplinary action is every bit as incompetent as limiting the Planning function to a few days each year when the budgets and sales targets are formulated.
Of course, any specific manager may also be tasked with additional functions by higher management, and many professionals serving in the manager’s role will also have work of their own to complete. But the manager’s job itself remains the same – and has, in fact, since the first group of people began working on a project together. The only real questions facing the management professional are “Are you performing all four of these functions?” (you’d better be!) and “How do I perform all of these functions?”
Which is a topic for another day…
Labels:
Controlling,
Directing,
Management,
Organizing,
Planning
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
