Saturday, November 3, 2007

The Hardest Business

Some time ago a client came to consult with me about writing the business plan for a new venture she wanted to start with her mother: a coffee house. Now, with the huge increase in coffee sales in recent years, and the ongoing proliferation of coffee houses, there isn’t really much doubt that you can make a relatively large amount of money selling coffee. True, the big chains have swept up much of the market, but there is still a niche for local institutions; neighborhood coffee houses that don’t look, smell, sound and taste just like 8,000 other locations throughout the United States, Canada, and Europe. The problem was that my client and her mother wanted to go into the business because their current jobs (they were both accountants) were too difficult, and they wanted to do less work.

Needless to say, neither of them had ever worked in food service before. Had they done so, they would probably have realized what everyone else who has ever tried their hand in this industry already knows: that it’s the hardest business to survive in, let alone make money. If you’d rather not take my word for it, there was an excellent article in Slate Magazine about two years ago (or about three years AFTER the consultation in question) explaining the economics of a small coffee house and why you can expect to go mad trying to make a go of one. Of course, not all locations are as demanding as New York City, but most other locations also lack the population density that gives NYC its unique mass of customers. Generally speaking, most other locations are a wash.

My clients had been expecting to start their workday every morning at 9 am, 8:00 at the earliest. I pointed out to them that this would mean abandoning all of the morning rush hour customers to whatever chain coffee vendor happened to be nearby, and suggested that they’d probably need to get in by 5 am to get ready for a 6 am opening (5:30 would be better). They both got this look, like a deer in the headlights, as they contemplated getting up at 4:00 am every morning. They had also expected to close at 6 pm, until I pointed out that this would mean giving the after-dinner, after-theater, late night and evening commute business to the competition. Closing before 10:00 pm would mean throwing away more money, and Midnight would be better. If they intended to bake their own baked goods, they’d need to get in by 4 am to get dough in the oven by 5 for a 6 am opening, and they’d have to count on another hour at close to wash dishes if they were going to serve food.

By this point, the “deer in the headlights” look had gotten a bit fixed, and we hadn’t even started on the amount of coffee they would need to sell each day in order to stay in business, the physical demands of running such a business, or the difficulties they would face in trying to get financing for such a project from bankers who would already know about all of these issues and would not be eager to advance money on a project this risky. But the worst part of the whole proposition is that even if they had managed to complete all of the preparation, overcome all of the development tasks, launch their enterprise and live with the insane hours and crushing physical demands of the work, their coffee house might still have failed. Because, you see, in food service, you don’t actually have to be selling an inferior product to lose all of your customers; people just have to BELIEVE that you do…

I’m not sure what became of my clients; I suggested they rethink the project and get back to me. They never did. Hopefully they’ve settled on some form of start up business that will allow you to work less than 8 hours each day, only 5 days per week, with no risks and no need for start-up capital – and if anyone out there knows what kind of business that would be, I’d appreciate it if you’d drop me a line and let ME know.

Because I’ve never heard of such a thing…

Thursday, November 1, 2007

Subliminal Advertising

I was watching one of the new Kia Motors ads the other day, and happened to comment on what a wonderful example of subliminal advertising I thought it was. Now, we’ve all heard the stories about movie theaters supposedly flashing the word “popcorn” for a split second (one frame?) during a movie, or a picture of a plate of fried clams that actually contains concealed images of an orgy. All of which have been repeatedly debunked over the years – there is no evidence of any kind to suggest that these sorts of suggestions actually work. But there IS a different kind of subliminal advertising that has always been with us, and the commercial in question is an excellent example.

The ad is structured to look and sound like an ad for a dating service, only in this case the “match” being made is between a consumer and an inexpensive car, not between two single people. What makes it subliminal advertising is the choice of characters in the ad – one of whom is a young, attractive blonde woman. Since the key demo for most car ads is males, ages 18 to 36, the implication is clear: if you purchase one of these cars, you’re actually purchasing the blonde. The fact that the character is completely passive (she has no spoken lines, and is clearly willing to accept being “paired” with whoever or whatever the Kia people tell her to accept) simply completes the illusion; if this woman is agreeable enough to buy a Kia when told to do so, heaven only knows what else she might put up with. Maybe the male viewer has a chance after all…

Of course, this is nothing new; companies have been using attractive spokesmodels to sell cars for years, with the car serving as a surrogate for the attractive woman, but in an attainable form. Very few men can actually hope to have a supermodel as their significant other, but anyone with a few dollars a month to spend can have a new Kia. The same approach is used to sell all manner of consumer products, although the most familiar examples after cars are probably beer and personal grooming items – use our products and women like these will want to sleep with you is the message being employed. In recent years these ads have become so clichéd that some companies have actually begun using them as parody or self-parody, such as in the Axe Body Spray commercials, where use of the product quite literally results in the user being attacked by lust-crazed females.

From a business standpoint, this form of advertising makes sense only if the gain in sales realized outweighs the negative reaction that will almost certainly come from feminist groups, conservative political organizations, advertising bloggers and other people with no sense of humor. No matter how harmless the subliminal message is – even if the attractive woman is fully clothed and never does anything more suggestive than award a gold star to a successful pupil – someone somewhere is going to condemn the ad as sexist, racist, ageist, or otherwise offensive. If our key demographic group is comprised of people who fall into one of those categories, then we should avoid using this type of advertising.

On the other hand, if our key demographic is Males, 18 to 36 years old, then the criticism of these ads is rather silly. In a free-market economy, companies exist to make money, and the suggestion that they ought to deliberately hamper themselves in order to avoid the risk of offending a segment of the population who will never do business with them anyway is ridiculous. As business people, the question we need to ask when approaching television ads, print ads, radio spots, Internet ads or even outdoor advertising is whether the piece we have developed has a second, underlying, suggestive meaning – and whether or not that will help us to meet our marketing goals…

Wednesday, October 31, 2007

Product Placement

Think back to the last time you were at the movies, and one of the characters was holding or using a product that you recognized; a food item, a laptop computer, a car, doesn’t matter, so long as it was a product that you could purchase for yourself if you had a mind to. Did it make you want to go out and buy the same product? Well, if not, somebody just blew a large amount of money for nothing. Product appearances like this are called Product Placements, and companies pay big money to have their product be the key item that James Bond uses to sold the puzzle, catch the bad guys, save the world, or just get the girl – in the hopes that you will believe that if you buy the same product you can get the fame, fortune, glory and/or sex.

In recent times, Product Placements have begun turning up in television shows, video games, even on the Internet, as audiences become more and more jaded (and therefore more and more immune to normal advertising stunts). In a straightforward business sense it’s a very clever idea – if your product is seen by all of the people who have tuned in to a hit television show, you’ve effectively reached the same number of people who would have seen a commercial placed in the same program slot, if you’d bought one. Even better, people won’t be out of the room getting a snack or going to the lavatory when your product placement hits the screen. Of course, you will only get a fraction of the screen time, but you’re probably not paying quite as much for the placement as you would for an ad.

An especially good example of this turned up on the Food Network’s program The Next Iron Chef over the weekend. Now, I know I promised to stop writing about reality TV, and about the Food Network in general, but this one was so good I’m going to forget that I did. This series follows eight competitors who are vying for a spot on the Iron Chef America program – a kind of “American Gladiators” meets “Survivor” contest in which a guest chef attempts to prepare better food than one of a group of champions who regularly appear (the “Iron Chefs” of the title), given a surprise secret ingredient and only one hour to perform.

To those of us who still eat food ordered by yelling into a clown’s head, this may seem a bit fantastical, but the title of “Iron Chef” is apparently taken quite seriously in the business. The eight competitors in the “Next Iron Chef” show have all be on the main program before, and in fact are all competitors who won. The Food Network therefore knows that they are good enough to compete and win (at least once) and telegenic enough to appeal to the television audience. How much of this spin-off is an actual competition and how much of it is just an extended audition I couldn’t tell you; I’m not sure anyone short of the Network executives really knows. What I do know is that in the last episode they had one of the best product placements I’ve ever seen.

The challenge was to come up with a new airline meal suitable for the best first class service in the world, featuring an Airbus A380 (the newest, biggest and fanciest airliner ever built) in service with Lufthansa (the airline generally considered to have the best food in the sky). The product placement was an actual A380, in Lufthansa colors, in which the competitors had to prepare their offerings for the judges. I’m not sure if it was Lufthansa or Airbus who came up with this, but either way it was brilliant. Airbus got to show off their newest (and most expensive) creation and have the show gush over how fancy it was, and Lufthansa got to preen about how good their food was. I suspect that both companies were in on it; certainly, they both got terrific value for their advertising dollar…

Sunday, October 28, 2007

The Ethics of Mediocrity

The subject of motivational theory came up at lunch the other day, when the comment was floated just before the entrees arrived that perhaps the reason so many people appear to be just barely passable at their jobs is that most people will only put forth the minimum effort necessary to avoid being fired, and no more than that. This led almost immediately to a brisk discussion of just what, exactly, that minimum level would be, and how you would determine it across the huge range of job and performance requirements in the workplace. This is going to vary quite a bit, depending on which employees we are discussing and what their job actually requires of them.

For example, a CEO’s job is technically to maximize stockholder value, and anything less than that will probably get him or her fired – except that what, exactly, the maximum possible value of a given stock actually is at any given time is a matter than can be (and usually is) endlessly debated by everyone who monitors the stock market, shareholder or not. By the same token, the hostess running the front desk at a restaurant has only one job function: greet incoming customers, make them feel welcome, and get them a table or other place to sit. What exactly constitutes “feeling welcome” will vary a bit, but if the hostess is scowling and unfriendly (like the one who had “greeted” us at lunch that day), she’s clearly not doing the only job function she has.

My question is this: suppose that you have completed all of the tasks assigned to you, and met every performance target your superiors wanted you to meet. Do you, at that point, have any ethical responsibility to work even harder, accomplish more tasks and exceed those performance targets? Some employers, as is so amply parodied in the Dilbert comic strip, believe that the employees owe them every waking second (and sometimes the contents of their dreams at night, as well), to the point that even having a personal life is like “stealing from the company.” Such organizations would be appalled at the very idea of an employee not working to the absolute utmost edge of their ability, punish anyone they feel is not in fact doing so, and thereby almost guarantee that everyone working for them will slack off whenever possible.

At the opposite end of the spectrum are companies where working more than you are assigned to work is frowned upon, because it makes everyone else look bad, rather like the legendary Post Office branches where coming back from your assigned 4-hour delivery route in less than four hours is considered at sin, even if your route only involved delivering two envelopes and a mail-order catalog. Such companies are unlikely to suffer heavy turnover, but they’re not likely to experience much growth, either. Some organizations will offer performance incentives, such as bonuses for doing more work, or else base raises and promotions on performance targets, but this doesn’t really apply to the question I’m asking; working more in order to get paid more isn’t a matter of ethics, just common sense.

Suppose your pay will be the same if you do 100% of your work, or 110% of the workload assigned, or 250% of your workload. Let us further assume that you can accomplish the extra work without unbalancing the rest of your life (working nights and never seeing your family, for example) or other extreme measures, and that no financial incentives will ever be offered and promotion will not come this side of the grave. Do you have a purely ethical responsibility to give your employer more than they have asked for? Or at least inform them that you are seriously underemployed? And if not, are you in any way to blame if the organization as a whole fails to meet its performance goals?

It’s worth thinking about…

Thursday, October 25, 2007

How Far Is Too Far?

The age-old question of how far should we go in order to advertise a product came around again this week, with the revived controversy over the use of “ball girls” at the Madrid Master’s tennis tournament. You can check out some of the pictures on MSN/Fox Sports if you want to. But you already know the story: a pack of models is rounded up from agencies in Spain, asked a few questions about tennis and then issued skimpy dresses with the sponsor’s name and logo on them (and even skimpier instructions about what to do) and stationed at courtside.

Almost as obvious was the immediate response from just about all quarters. People who take the sport of tennis too seriously claimed that having scantily-clad models working on the court made a mockery of the tournament. Easily-offended people claimed that having scantily-clad models working on the court was sexist, exploitive, offensive, or otherwise discriminatory, and some of the players (almost always those who had just lost a match they were expected to win) claimed that having scantily-clad models working on the court distracted them from the game at critical moments.

I should note that the WTA event held in the same venue employs male models in the same role, so it’s hard to make any charge of sexism stick. And the female players certainly don’t appear to have had any trouble keeping their minds on the game. Personally, I have to add that if you can’t keep you mind on a game that allows you to earn millions of dollars a year, travel the world, and generally do whatever you want, you need professional help, not less attractive ball girls. But from a business standpoint, the question this post is actually about is a lot more basic: Is the sponsor employing the models (in this case it’s Hugo Boss) going too far in their efforts to promote their product line? And if not, then exactly how far is too far?

Basic management theory tells us that if an advertising measure brings in more business than the total cost of producing the advertising (including any business lost from people who are too offended by the ad to purchase the product), then the ads were effective. In this particular case, Hugo Boss may appear to be losing a fair amount of business from the easily-offended demographic, but since their key market segment (single males 18-36) is unlikely to be offended by having scantily-clad models police up balls at a tennis match, the business loss isn’t all that high. The cost of employing a pack of models for the duration of a tennis tournament will certainly cost them a fair amount, but when you factor in all of the free publicity generated by the controversy over this advertising measure, I’d have to say it looks promising. And there certainly aren’t any other costs involved; no space to buy in print, no airtime for television to purchase, no billboards to produce, rent and install.

Of course, if you are the sort of person who is offended by the idea of skinny young women in short dresses running around in public, you’d probably say that the overall cost to society is too great to justify whatever profits Hugo Boss makes from sponsoring the “ball girls” in Madrid. But from a purely business standpoint, I’d have to say that the measure is drawing huge amounts of attention from the media and the public, getting the sponsor’s name and logo seen all over the world, and not actually costing very much to produce. It’s hard to see how it could be any better for Hugo Boss. As for the male tennis players, perhaps a dose of saltpeter before each match would be in order…

Wednesday, October 24, 2007

Stakeholder Theory

I was in the Library this week working on something else when I ran across several articles about Stakeholder Theory. It’s another one of those ideas that is so simple that you could probably design an entire Master’s class around it; there are certainly a large number of articles in management journals that deal with the concept. It takes a special sort of person to attempt to explain something that big in 600 words or less; I’ll let the reader decide if I’m arrogant or just crazy for trying.

The first thing to keep in mind is the definition of a stakeholder. Although there is some debate over how broad to make the definition, in general, a stakeholder is anyone affected by a specific company’s operations, including their employees, shareholders, suppliers, and customers, but also including political groups, trade unions, the communities in which the company’s products are made, sold or used, prospective customers, and so on. Stakeholder theory basically states that in order to be strategically sound, a company’s plans should take all of the stakeholders into account, not just the ones who own shares in the company.

This is, of course, a complete departure from the older theory of management, which holds that a company’s primary duty (some would say its only duty) is to generate revenue, and that the management team’s job is to maximize shareholder value. Since the shareholders are literally the people who own the company, and since they can (at least in theory) fire the CEO and the board and replace them, it would seem to behoove the top management personnel to look after the interests of the shareholders; it can also be argued that they have a fiduciary duty to do just that. On the other hand, the stakeholders include many people with no ownership position in the company and no way to punish or reward the management team; in some cases, even the company’s competitors are considered to be stakeholders. So why should the management team attempt to do right by them?

Let me give you two concrete examples. In 1971, Ford Motor Company decided to bury the reports about the Pinto, thus maximizing their share value and the stockholder’s investment at the expense of anyone who owned a Pinto or happened to run into the back of one. They were eventually exposed, vigorously sued, and lost even more money than they would have spent to fix the faulty gas tanks. However, even worse was the loss of the company’s reputation; the public was less confident in the safety of their cars, and investors were less confident in the management of the company. The fallout from that blunder is STILL being felt within the company, none of it good.

By contrast, in 1982 someone managed to put poison into bottles of Tylenol, killing seven people and starting a nationwide panic. The Johnson and Johnson company responded by doing everything it could to help the families of the victims and starting a drive to create tamper-proof packaging that eventually became the industry standard. Now all over-the-counter drugs (and many other products) come with the same tamper-resistant packaging Johnson and Johnson came up with to protect its stakeholders. As a result, their company is widely regarded as being responsible, taking care of its customers, and most importantly of all, being intelligently run. The money spent on the tamper-resistant packaging and in the cleanup after the poisoning scare have been made back many times over by the improved public perception, and the shareholders’ overall value is far higher than it would have been if the company had attempted to stonewall, blame the victims, or deny responsibility.

In other words, the ultimate outcome of stakeholder theory is that if you run your company in a responsible manner, taking into consideration all of the people affected by your operations (and not just the ones who own your common stock), you can expect to do better in the long run than if you cling to the concept of maximizing shareholder value at the expense of everything else. Or, if you like, the argument in favor of stakeholder theory is simple, enlightened self-interest…

Tuesday, October 23, 2007

Scalping and Hacking

Earlier this month, I had occasion to comment in this space about the Major League Baseball playoffs and the issue of ticket scalping; you can see my entries on Lovable Losers? and Getting Scalped respectively, if you missed either of them the first time. But today, I am pleased to bring you a story that combines both of these themes with the always-vexing subject of computer hacking.

As you may know, the World Series starts this week, and features the teams from Colorado (the Rockies) and Boston (the Red Sox) in what some are calling a classic duel between a club that has one only one world series title since trading Babe Ruth to the Yankees nearly a century ago, and a club that has only been around 12 years and has never won anything of significance in that time. What you may not know is that within an hour or so of the tickets going on sale over the Internet, the Rockies’ ticket sales web site crashed, preventing any of the 8.5 MILLION people who attempted to purchase tickets from getting anything, even access to the site. You can read the Associated Press story about these events if you missed it.

Now comes the news that the crash was not caused by the high volume of people clamoring for tickets. Rockies officials are announcing that their site was the target of a direct, external attack that required shutting it down until the early hours of this morning. Officials from Paciolan Inc., the company that runs the Rockies’ online ticket sales site says the attack had affected their entire North American network, causing a shutdown of every system they run. The company assured the AP that none of this was the Rockies’ fault, and that the system would be back up shortly.

Meanwhile, in Colorado, Rockies fans have been completely frantic, trying anything they can to get onto the site and purchase their tickets at face value before the scalpers get hold of all of them and jack up the price by the usual $300 or $400 per ticket. Locals have reported long lines of people waiting to get into the public library and use the high-speed terminals there (in the hopes of getting onto the ticket site faster), only to be disappointed at having no greater success than they had at home.

I think the situation makes several interesting business points, which is why I’m wasting both my time and yours (if you’re bothering to read this) making this entry. First, this is the biggest business opportunity the Colorado ball club has ever had, and if their success in the last month really does turn out to be the fluke the statisticians are calling it, Denver may never see the like of it again. That being the case, screwing up the ticket sales, alienating your loyal fans, and (worst of all!) failing to take their money is, well, stupid. Second, outsourcing your ticket site only makes sense if the company you’ve outsourced it to can take care of you ticket sales BOTH more cheaply and more reliably than you could have in house. Otherwise, this was also stupid.

But I think the most important point to be made here is that during the past year, we have witnessed giant, multi-billion dollar companies suing people without a dime to their names over illegal music downloads that don’t actually cost the music companies anything (since these people would not have been able to afford the files they “shared” in the first place; it’s not that they had the money and chose not to spend it), yet nothing is done about large ticket brokerage companies snapping up thousands of tickets and then screwing every possible cent out of the people who would have paid the face value of those tickets – if they were allowed to. Meanwhile, the company being paid large sums of money to ensure that ordinary people get a fair chance to purchase tickets for their own personal use has just about guaranteed that the ticket brokers will get all of the available tickets sometime between midnight and dawn tomorrow, and spend the rest of the week happily putting the screws to the baseball fans in Denver.

Somehow, “stupid” seems far too mild a term for this. The only thing I can imagine that would be worse would be actually shelling out $450 for tickets with a face value of $8. But I’m pretty sure that someone will…