The subject of motivational theory came up at lunch the other day, when the comment was floated just before the entrees arrived that perhaps the reason so many people appear to be just barely passable at their jobs is that most people will only put forth the minimum effort necessary to avoid being fired, and no more than that. This led almost immediately to a brisk discussion of just what, exactly, that minimum level would be, and how you would determine it across the huge range of job and performance requirements in the workplace. This is going to vary quite a bit, depending on which employees we are discussing and what their job actually requires of them.
For example, a CEO’s job is technically to maximize stockholder value, and anything less than that will probably get him or her fired – except that what, exactly, the maximum possible value of a given stock actually is at any given time is a matter than can be (and usually is) endlessly debated by everyone who monitors the stock market, shareholder or not. By the same token, the hostess running the front desk at a restaurant has only one job function: greet incoming customers, make them feel welcome, and get them a table or other place to sit. What exactly constitutes “feeling welcome” will vary a bit, but if the hostess is scowling and unfriendly (like the one who had “greeted” us at lunch that day), she’s clearly not doing the only job function she has.
My question is this: suppose that you have completed all of the tasks assigned to you, and met every performance target your superiors wanted you to meet. Do you, at that point, have any ethical responsibility to work even harder, accomplish more tasks and exceed those performance targets? Some employers, as is so amply parodied in the Dilbert comic strip, believe that the employees owe them every waking second (and sometimes the contents of their dreams at night, as well), to the point that even having a personal life is like “stealing from the company.” Such organizations would be appalled at the very idea of an employee not working to the absolute utmost edge of their ability, punish anyone they feel is not in fact doing so, and thereby almost guarantee that everyone working for them will slack off whenever possible.
At the opposite end of the spectrum are companies where working more than you are assigned to work is frowned upon, because it makes everyone else look bad, rather like the legendary Post Office branches where coming back from your assigned 4-hour delivery route in less than four hours is considered at sin, even if your route only involved delivering two envelopes and a mail-order catalog. Such companies are unlikely to suffer heavy turnover, but they’re not likely to experience much growth, either. Some organizations will offer performance incentives, such as bonuses for doing more work, or else base raises and promotions on performance targets, but this doesn’t really apply to the question I’m asking; working more in order to get paid more isn’t a matter of ethics, just common sense.
Suppose your pay will be the same if you do 100% of your work, or 110% of the workload assigned, or 250% of your workload. Let us further assume that you can accomplish the extra work without unbalancing the rest of your life (working nights and never seeing your family, for example) or other extreme measures, and that no financial incentives will ever be offered and promotion will not come this side of the grave. Do you have a purely ethical responsibility to give your employer more than they have asked for? Or at least inform them that you are seriously underemployed? And if not, are you in any way to blame if the organization as a whole fails to meet its performance goals?
It’s worth thinking about…
Showing posts with label Theory X. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Theory X. Show all posts
Sunday, October 28, 2007
Wednesday, August 1, 2007
A Couple Days Off
The question came up a couple of days ago after a death in our family about why so many employers are as rigid about bereavement leave as they are. My wife works for an organization that allows time off in the event of the death of a family member, including parents, grandparents, siblings, aunts, uncles, children, and step- and in-law versions of all of the above; however, many (perhaps most) employers will only recognize the original versions of these people (not in-laws or step-relatives), and some limit this benefit to “immediate family” – e.g. parents, children, or spouses. Why on Earth would anyone be such a hard case as to deny someone who has just lost a grandparent – or a step-parent – time off of work?
It’s tempting to assume that this sort of policy is the result of managers who are either too lazy to work out a more enlightened method or too mean-spirited to try to work with their people instead of treating employees as the enemy. Some people would point out that given a liberal bereavement leave policy, there are workers who would experience a loss every Monday before work – or at least claim to have done so, in order to gain more paid time off.
As usual, this issue is a bit more complicated than it initially appears to be. What is really at the heart of the matter is the question of whether employees are inherently lazy (and will avoid work if they can), or whether employees may also be ambitious and self-motivated. In management science, these two concepts are called Theory X and Theory Y, and were first suggested by Douglas McGregor at MIT in 1960. Theory Y is often considered to be the practical application of the Humanistic School of Psychology developed by our old friend Abraham Maslow (see my prior ramblings about the Hierarchy of Needs).
It’s worth noting that McGregor himself did not claim that either Theory X or Theory Y were in any way “correct” descriptions of humanity in general; indeed, he believed that both of them were merely generalizations applicable to SOME employees, and hoped that managers would investigate both sets of beliefs as a means of developing new and better management strategies. The fact is that some people will take advantage of any system and abuse any benefits offered to them, while others will attempt to work within the system and take only those benefits to which they are legitimately entitled. It is the manager’s job to keep the Theory X people in line, just as much as it is to make sure the Theory Y people take the leave to which they are entitled (not refuse it “for the good of the company”).
Ultimately, policy can not replace the work of the management team, no matter how liberal or employee-friendly that policy happens to be. One large company I worked for had no set leave policy of any kind – sick leave, bereavement leave, and family leave were all purely at the discretion of the management team at the local level. Only vacation time was computed according to a set formula, and even then, scheduling was at the manager’s discretion. It takes an extremely capable manager to handle that kind of responsibility without creating bad feelings, conflicts or lawsuits, but I can tell you for a certainty that no one in my work group or my division was ever denied a few days off to be with their family in a time of loss…
It’s tempting to assume that this sort of policy is the result of managers who are either too lazy to work out a more enlightened method or too mean-spirited to try to work with their people instead of treating employees as the enemy. Some people would point out that given a liberal bereavement leave policy, there are workers who would experience a loss every Monday before work – or at least claim to have done so, in order to gain more paid time off.
As usual, this issue is a bit more complicated than it initially appears to be. What is really at the heart of the matter is the question of whether employees are inherently lazy (and will avoid work if they can), or whether employees may also be ambitious and self-motivated. In management science, these two concepts are called Theory X and Theory Y, and were first suggested by Douglas McGregor at MIT in 1960. Theory Y is often considered to be the practical application of the Humanistic School of Psychology developed by our old friend Abraham Maslow (see my prior ramblings about the Hierarchy of Needs).
It’s worth noting that McGregor himself did not claim that either Theory X or Theory Y were in any way “correct” descriptions of humanity in general; indeed, he believed that both of them were merely generalizations applicable to SOME employees, and hoped that managers would investigate both sets of beliefs as a means of developing new and better management strategies. The fact is that some people will take advantage of any system and abuse any benefits offered to them, while others will attempt to work within the system and take only those benefits to which they are legitimately entitled. It is the manager’s job to keep the Theory X people in line, just as much as it is to make sure the Theory Y people take the leave to which they are entitled (not refuse it “for the good of the company”).
Ultimately, policy can not replace the work of the management team, no matter how liberal or employee-friendly that policy happens to be. One large company I worked for had no set leave policy of any kind – sick leave, bereavement leave, and family leave were all purely at the discretion of the management team at the local level. Only vacation time was computed according to a set formula, and even then, scheduling was at the manager’s discretion. It takes an extremely capable manager to handle that kind of responsibility without creating bad feelings, conflicts or lawsuits, but I can tell you for a certainty that no one in my work group or my division was ever denied a few days off to be with their family in a time of loss…
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)