Showing posts with label Journalism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Journalism. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 16, 2014

And Now a Word from Captain Obvious

If you spend as much time as I do looking for story fodder, there are certain types of “reporting” that are going to get on your nerves after a while. Wildly over-dramatic headlines are annoying, especially when the story is of no particular interest to anyone. Stories that bring up issues resolved years ago, crises for which suitable solutions were implemented in the last century or horrible cultural insults that no one even noticed, let alone protested, are just wastes of everybody’s time and bandwidth. And stories that attempt to create an issue where none exists – or, indeed, ever could – are just a huge nuisance all around. The best thing you can say for most of this flotsam cluttering up the Internet is that we aren’t killing and grinding up any more trees to print it on. But every once in a while, a story hits that combines two or more of these problems into a complete morass of suck…

Take, for example, a recent Rolling Stone online article about “The 5 Most Dangerous Guns in America.” This sounds like it could be a controversial but hard-hitting look at the gun types and models that are used in the largest number of crimes, the ones that are the most easily obtained and/or stolen, the ones that can be most easily modified for various sinister purposes, the ones that are the hardest to detect and therefore the greatest threats to public safety, the ones most often used in workplace shootings, the ones most often used in school shootings, the ones most often used in drive-by shootings, or even the ones that are most likely to fail in spectacular ways and kill the person wielding, cleaning, or standing in front of them. Unfortunately, that would require research, interviews and analysis – what used to be called “journalism” back when people still did any of those things…

Instead, this “article” lists just five categories of guns: pistols, revolvers, rifles, shotguns and derringers. Throughout the six pages, the author uses FBI and BATF data to present the total number of each gun type recovered at crime scenes in 2012, all of which tells us exactly nothing. Consider, for example, that according to the ATF something over 119,000 automatic pistols were found at crime scenes in 2012. That would include non-violent crimes, misdemeanors like trespassing and jaywalking, and suicides (in most municipalities suicide is a crime as well as a tragedy); it also gives us no idea of the relative safety or lethality of these weapons or how many of these “crimes” were eventually dismissed as self-defense. And while the raw number may sound like a lot, 119,000 isn’t actually a particularly impressive fraction of the 150 million to 200 million handguns estimated to exist in the United States alone…

Now, we should probably acknowledge that this story would have been controversial no matter what happened. The fact is that any gun can be deadly if the person firing it can hit the target, and the most dangerous gun in almost any situation is the one being held by a person who does not know how to use it safely. But the worst part of this type of reporting is that it replaces any opportunity for meaningful dialog about gun-related violence with nonsensical scare-mongering. Those five types of gun represent almost every kind of firearm normally available to the general public (black powder weapons and specialty types not withstanding); one might just as well say that most traffic accidents are caused by cars, trucks, SUVs, motorcycles, vans and buses (including RV types). In other words, it’s a statement so self-evident and meaningless that even Captain Obvious himself would hesitate to bring it up…

I don’t have any easy answers for the ongoing gun control debate; I don’t believe there are any. And even if I did, I don’t believe a blog about business and management topics would be the right place to air them. I’m just saying that if I owned any news source in any medium I would fire anybody who approved this sort of blather for publication – and then I’d assign the reporter to do some actual research for a change...

Tuesday, July 24, 2007

Journalistic Idiocy

By now, any of you who are going to buy the 7th and last Harry Potter book (which some Internet wags have already started calling “Harry Potter and the Truckload of Money”) have already done so; most of you have already read it. Some of you are probably still outraged at the New York Times for publishing its “early review” of the book, two days before it went on sale. I will leave the debates over free trade and freedom of speech to those individuals (and bloggers) better informed about such things, and just point out to anyone who may be reading today that from a business standpoint this was the height of journalistic idiocy, a move that can not benefit (and can greatly harm) the Times. It is, oh now there’s that word again… STUPID!

And it’s not even the dumbest thing the Times has done regarding the Harry Potter series…

Needless to say, the Times is defending its right to review the book once it was available for purchase. A spokesperson for the paper went on record as saying “Our feeling is that once a book is offered up for sale at any public, retail outlet, and we purchase a copy legally and openly, we are free to review it. We came across a copy of ‘Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows’ at a store in New York City and we bought it.”

I’m not sure if any of this is legal; certainly no retailer in North America had the contractual rights to sell the book before 12:01 am on July 21st. Even if it is, it does not excuse the blind stupidity of the exercise. With something like 9,000,000 copies of the book pre-ordered and tens of thousands of people lining up for release parties around the world, there are very few people who are going to make their purchasing decision based on the New York Times review. Either you don’t read the series, or you were already planning to read the book. Which means that this early review serves no purpose beyond displaying the fact that the Times got a copy three or four days early.

Then there’s the whole business about reorganizing the bestseller list. As blogger Michael Giltz points out in the Huffington Post, the change in recent years that makes “children’s books” a different category is a direct result of the success of the Harry Potter series, and guarantees that “Deathly Hallows” will never make the New York Times bestseller list, despite being the hottest-selling book in the past four hundred years or so.

Of course, as Giltz points out, without the early volumes’ success on that very list, the series might never have found its current audience. In which case, it’s possible that the later volumes would never have been written, and it’s almost certain that the millions of children who have become interested in reading because of the Potter series would be off playing video games instead.

I can’t see the advantage to the New York Times of lowering the number of readers going forward, since they depend on readership to stay in business. Leaving aside the issue of when the book review page became part of the op-ed page (the bestseller list is just supposed to TRACK sales, not comment on them!), all this does is undermine reader confidence in the Times itself, and decrease the paper’s credibility in a time when, following the Jason Blair scandal, they are already suffering.

Again, I can’t say if this violates journalistic responsibility or not. I can only tell you that, purely from a business standpoint, it’s amazingly (there’s that word again…) STUPID!