Pork in Space! Rides Again

I’ve written in this space any number of times about “pork-barrel” spending by the Federal government; mostly stories about expenditures of tax dollars that make no sense from any operational standpoint but are good for companies that donate money to the politicians who vote for those expenditures. It’s important to note that this behavior is not limited to any one political party, geographic region, or level of government; the projects vary a bit depending on who is controlling the budget at the time, but whether the government is spending money on airplanes that the military is sending directly to the Boneyard or entitlement programs that don’t help anyone, the principle is the same. That said, the current Administration’s new “Space Force” initiative is a particularly silly example of the process…

If you missed it, back in March the President announced that he had just come up with the idea of a new (sixth) branch of the U.S. military, which he called the “Space Force.” This isn’t really a new idea, of course; several previous attempts have been made to establish a permanent armed service in space, most recently in 2016 with the ill-fated “Space Corps” proposal. These have generally failed, either because there was no clear mission for the space service to perform, the proposed technology was either unavailable or economically unfeasible, or because the proposed installations contravened the Outer Space Treaty of 1967 (which prohibits the placement of weapons of mass destruction in orbit, on the Moon, or on any other celestial body). None of this has kept various administrations from shoveling money into those projects, however…

What is remarkable about the current incarnation of the program is how little effort the government is making to convince anyone that it isn’t just a giant boondoggle, almost exactly the same concept as the 2016 “Space Corps” proposal only with additional pork-barrel funding for satellites, launch vehicles, and gold-plated bonuses for the extremely wealthy people who own the aerospace companies. It would be nice to think that this had anything to do with forward-thinking defense or security planning, or at the very least, that it was an intelligent effort to stimulate economic growth in a high-tech sector in which the U.S. still has a fairly strong position relative to the rest of the world. Unfortunately, it appears to be the result of significant lobbying efforts by the aerospace industry – and the extraordinary receptiveness of the current administration to anything that gives away public money to its political backers…

You can check out the excellent story about all of this from the Los Angeles Times if you’d like more details on the political aspects. On the business side, the question isn’t so much why our government wants to spend more money on flying pork (every U.S. administration wants to spend more money on every kind of pork), but why this proposal includes a massive duplication of personnel (particularly management levels), headquarters facilities, equipment, and spacecraft, when the Air Force, Army and Navy all have space-oriented units currently operating. One might quite reasonably suggest that an increased focus on (non-nuclear) space-based weapons could be important to national security, given the equivalent programs appearing in both the Russian and the Chinese militaries. What baffles me is why anyone, even aerospace industry lobbyists, would want to do so in the least financially responsible way possible…