Wednesday, October 3, 2007

A Good Idea?

I saw a notice on television last night that said NBC was breaking off its working relationship with Apple, and would no longer be offering its programming for sale through the iTunes store. Instead, NBC will be offering its programming free of charge on its own new download site, called NBC Direct. You can try it out for yourself if you want to; just go to http://www.nbc.com/.

Obviously, the network is hoping to attract a huge number of new viewers to its downloadable content, since people will be able to get all they want for free. It’s an attractive offer on its face, but there are a couple of things they don’t mention up front. For one, the “free” downloads are actually supported by advertising, just like broadcast television. That means that when you download a show off of NBC Direct, it comes with commercials as part of the download, and they’ve rigged the files so that you can’t fast-forward through the commercial part of the file when viewing it. You could still get up and go to the toilet during the commercials (thus not watching them), but short of actually leaving the room, you’re stuck with them.

Early reports also claim that if you don’t watch the download for two days, you will have to re-download the files before you can view them. This is supposed to assure that NBC can send you the very latest commercial content. And each of these “free” downloads is supposedly viewable for 7 days only, after which the file content erases itself (and is presumably not available for future downloads). No one has said what good that is supposed to do anyone, but I suppose if you have to keep downloading new files, that would give the network continual opportunities to deliver new commercial content.

Again, I’m not going near any of the 1st Amendment or Privacy issues here. From a business standpoint, the question is, does this constitute a sound management decision? It is possible that the number of people willing to put up with all of these restrictions and commercials in order to get free content will generate enough viewings for NBC to meet its contractual obligations to the sponsors of these shows, and thus make more money than they would selling the same content on iTunes. It’s also possible that they’ve misjudged the demographic of people who download television shows onto their iPods (many of whom could afford to pay for content in the first place, and many of whom will not stand for this kind of interference).

For the moment, the whole concept is mostly being mocked – I first picked up on this story on The Colbert Report, who were not what you would call merciful in their treatment of the mandatory commercials in the file. But it occurs to me that if NBC is not getting enough takers to make their new download site a going concern (e.g. not enough downloads to interest their advertising customers) it would be easy for them to return to selling the content. All they would have to do is add another “download now” button to their NBC Direct web site – one button that says “free – with commercials” and another that says “commercial free – three dollars” or however much they charge for content you can get for free over the airwaves anyway. They could even come up with an “enhanced” version of each show (commentary, extras, games, whatever) for a few dollars more, and add a third download button.

The possible downside is that the number of people who actually download television shows to watch on their iPods is small enough and those people resent the network’s attempts to control their viewing enough that they lose these viewers altogether. Which might not seem likely at first, but remember, this is the network that brought you the Olympic Triplecast…

Monday, October 1, 2007

A Time To Worry

This morning’s financial news included a modest-looking notice that Wal-Mart is starting its Christmas sales early this year, having already lowered prices on what its forecasters believe will be the most popular toys and games. You can catch the story on CNN online here if you want to. Not really anything ominous, at least not in an age where the headlines often include war casualties, erosion of our Constitutional rights, global warming, terrorist threats and Paris Hilton. Yet, if we take a closer look at the story, I’d have to say that anyone in the retail, consumer products or wholesale sectors should be feeling a little uneasy this morning – as should anyone connected to those industries as vendors, suppliers, customers or investors. Which means pretty much everyone but the military…

First off, let’s consider the effect of Wal-Mart lowering prices on these product categories just in itself. Every time they do this, Wal-Mart is taking market share away from other companies, particularly when they lower the prices to the point where there is no remaining profit (a “loss leader” strategy – see my post about those here). This is bad for other retailers, of course, especially general merchandise stores, which will also lose the sales they would have made of non-toy merchandise that the people who came in to buy toys won’t purchase now because they’ve gone to Wal-Mart instead. For stores that have no other product categories (e.g. toy stores) this Wal-Mart sale could intercept all of their holiday sales, and eliminate as much as half of their annual revenue. For an independent toy store, this could easily mean bankruptcy.

The effect isn’t limited to retail stores, either. My contacts in the toy industry tell me that Wal-Mart gets a lot of its deep discounts by putting the screws to their suppliers – effectively telling the manufacturers that unless they give Wal-Mart a special, favorable price on these key products, Wal-Mart will refuse to carry ANY of their products. Wal-Mart is also ruthless about returns, credits, shipping policies, and famous for its indifference to vendor relations. In effect, they will treat their vendors as badly as possible – because they can.

But as bad as this is for business in and of itself, the projected cause of this Wal-Mart toy bonanza is the really chilling bit of news in this story. CNN speculates that retailers may be nervous about weak holiday sales because of weak consumer confidence and the inability of many consumers to get or maintain credit – both side effects of the ongoing mortgage crisis and the weakening housing market. With quite literally half of the year’s revenue anticipated in the next three months, and as much as 80% of the year’s toy sales expected during the same period, any major breakdown of consumer spending – now – will have a massive ripple effect in the economy.

Of course, Wal-Mart and the other major retailers (Target, Toys “R” Us, K-Mart, etc.) are already worried about all of the toy recalls in the past few months, which may already have undermined confidence in some toy categories, not to mention the downturn in the economy already being caused by the failure of mortgage companies and lending institutions. I don’t know if the smaller retail companies, vendors and investors are frightened yet; I only know that if a behemoth like Wal-Mart is running scared, it’s time to worry…

Sunday, September 30, 2007

The Ethics of Loyalty

If you’re a Dodgers fan (and heaven knows I’m not suggesting anyone should be after this year), you’ve probably been hearing a lot lately about how the team’s veteran players are blaming this season’s collapse (from the best record in the Major Leagues two months ago to 4th place in their division today) on the younger players and the mistakes, poor cooperation, and attitude being given off by the younger players. Meanwhile, those same younger athletes are pointing out that the complaining veterans have all struggled this year, turning in lackluster performances while the team has tried to cope with injuries and other problems. It would be nice to dismiss all of this on a bunch of grown men making millions of dollars to play a kid’s game – and then whining about it. Unfortunately, the situation is all too similar to a problem every manager will face sooner or later.

Let’s suppose for a moment that you need to promote one of your people. The new position will offer more responsibility, more money, and generally be seen as an advancement of the person selected. You would think that this would be simple: just select the person best suited to perform these new duties and promote him or her. If there is one person who is clearly the best choice (e.g., most experienced, best leader, best at doing their job, best at teaching others how to do the job) this should in fact be relatively simple; if not, you will have to figure out which of your people is the best in which of these areas, and try to select the best of the lot. If it’s a very close decision, you might even want to “interview” these people, and ask them how they would handle the new position. Unless you’ve been living in a cave somewhere for the past thirty years, however, you already know better than to favor people of a specific race, gender, ethnicity, age, height, size, weight, sexual preference or style of dress, so we will assume that you don’t.

Where things become murky is when you attempt to factor length of service into the equation. Some companies actually do consider seniority as a factor in promotion, holding that a person’s years with the company indicate their stability, maturity and loyalty in addition to familiarity with company policy and experience on the job. Other companies have a strict policy of “merit only” promotions – promote the best person for the job, even if that person has been around for a few months and everyone else in the department has decades of experience on the job. A company-wide policy may take the heat off of you, or at least give you something to blame for the choice you are being forced to make, but it does nothing to solve the underlying ethical problem.

Does the company owe its long-term employees anything in particular? Assuming they have been paid fair wages and given decent working conditions (including reasonable hours and livable benefits), does management owe them special consideration when issuing promotions? Or, perhaps more to the point, does the company’s obligation to support, reward and advance its loyal employees supersede its obligation to promote the best possible managers, thus maximizing performance and shareholder value? Especially when you consider that if your senior people believe they are being deliberately passed over for promotion (because the younger people will require lower salaries, for example) they are likely to leave the company seeking advancement elsewhere?

Of course, this same issue by definition touches on problems such as recognition (people see promotion as a public acknowledgement of their performance and abilities), security (people believe – often quite incorrectly – that higher-level people are less likely to be laid off or fired), morale (it’s demoralizing at best to be passed over; it can easily be insulting, depressing or infuriating, depending on whom you were passed over for) and employee retention (if the only way to obtain promotion and the attendant increase in responsibility, power, reputation and money is to change employers, people certainly will), but those issues will exist no matter how carefully we select people for promotion, and we can almost guarantee that someone will feel unjustly passed over no matter what we do. The question we as managers have to ask is where to draw that line between rewarding loyalty to the company and doing what is best for the company, on those (hopefully rare) occasions when these are not one and the same…

Saturday, September 29, 2007

What’s in a Package?

I noted with some interest an Internet story proclaiming this week as the 20th anniversary of the launch of Star Trek: The Next Generation, or ”Next Gen”, as the fans invariably call it. It’s hard to believe that 20 years have passed since the second regular series launched; it’s even harder to believe that the second series was able to generate even more support than its legendary predecessor, spawning three more “Star Trek” series and four movies staring the new cast. Even more amazing is that an idea Gene Roddenberry threw together in the 1960’s (“Wagon Train to the Stars” was Gene’s original pitch for the show) still has legs 20 years later – at least, if you count DVD sales.

I should come as no surprise that there’s a 20th Anniversary Edition boxed set coming onto the market this coming week featuring all 176 “Next Gen” episodes and lots of bonus material on 49 DVDs. After all, recent years have seen the introduction of boxed sets of hundreds of “classic” television shows, from early series like “The Honeymooners” and “I Love Lucy” to series still on the air today. The boxed set featuring the complete series of “Sex and the City” was on the market less than three months after the series wrapped (before the start of the next television season), and current hit shows usually have the previous season available before the current one starts.

Back when “Next Gen” was still on the air, I was working in cable television, and the boogeyman at that time was what we called “Video Dialtone” – television service provided over fiber-optical telephone lines (what is today called “broadband”). We were concerned about the advent of cable deregulation, the appearance of tiny satellite dishes that could fit on any roof, cable signal being made available via microwave, and of course, television over the Internet. Somehow, though, we never thought that entire television series would ever be made available in convenient forms the size of a paperback book. But we should have.

The development of DVD releases of old television shows is one of the best examples of re-packaging a product to have appeared in the past decade, and possibly the last century. To the companies that own the rights to these shows, the cost of producing a boxed set is minimal; production of the actual disks is trivial, and the printing of the boxes and liner notes isn’t much more expensive. In most cases, they already own the rights to all of the images, logos and likenesses they will need, as well as the property the disks will contain. There is probably a contractual obligation to pay the actors and creative people involved, but giving up a (usually tiny) percentage of the money you are raking in has never been much of an obstacle.

What may not be clear in all of this is how these sales are generated in the first place. There’s an impulse to dismiss this type of product sales as merely a fad, particularly in the case of Star Trek series or other programming with a cult following. But in point of fact, what gives these products their appeal is a combination of Convenience and Value Added. It would be relatively simple to record all of the episodes of any syndicated show, particularly one like Star Trek, which will be on cable at some time every single day. But these boxed sets feature all of the episodes, in their original broadcast order, all neatly recorded and labeled. Much more convenient than trying to record them yourself, or (worse yet) trying to find an episode you want to watch at the moment you want to watch it. The boxed sets also include bonus material (commentary, cast biographies, promotional items) in an attempt to provide value added; sometimes this makes the difference in the sales figures.

What we as business people can learn from this example is simple: never assume that just because public interest in your product has faded your product no longer has value. If disco music, 1970s fashions and “classic” television sitcoms can all continue to generate revenue in the 21st Century, your product probably can, too. It’s just a matter of finding a market that wants to purchase your product – and then finding a way to include convenience and/or added value in your packaging…

Thursday, September 27, 2007

Big Brother in Chicago

What do the city of Chicago, the IBM Corporation, and the guided-missile frigate U.S.S. Stark all have in common? Probably not very much at the moment, but that’s likely to change according to the article from the AP this morning about the new security surveillance system being installed in the Windy City. Basically, it’s a set of video cameras hooked up to logic units that can be set to look for specific images and react to pre-set events – such as spotting a specific license plate, or noticing that someone dropped a backpack in the park and then ran like heck. Here’s a link to the story on Yahoo News if you want to take a look at it.

Now, I’m not going to address any of the privacy vs. public safety issues in this space; I’m sticking to business issues. But somehow this reminds me of what happened to the Stark. In May of 1987, the Stark was on patrol in the Persian Gulf when it was attacked by two sea-skimming Exocet missiles fired by Iraqi warplanes. Here’s a summary of those events and their aftermath. In the investigations that followed, the question everyone wanted answered was why the ship had failed to defend itself. Inherent in this question is how a generic anti-ship missile costing less than $1 million at the time could inflict $142 million in damage on a front-line Navy vessel, kill 37 crewmen, and nearly sink the ship, especially giving the Stark was equipped with the best same-generation point defense systems.

It turned out that the missile defense system had been malfunctioning for weeks, and the crew had eventually turned it off because they were tired of dealing with almost constant false alarms. Now, I know it’s twenty years later, and the state-of-the-art has changed beyond recognition. In 1987 a 20-megabyte hard drive would have been hot stuff; today you might easily have 50 TIMES that much storage in a little gizmo attached to your keychain. But by the same token, a large urban center like Chicago has more activity going on – by several orders of magnitude – than the open sea in the Gulf. Programming the system to look for specific license plates (if it can actually do that) might be helpful if the police are actually looking for someone, but if the system summons the authorities every time someone puts down a backpack for 30 seconds (that’s the time frame given in the AP online story) that would be thousands of alerts every single day.

From a financial standpoint, the idea of spending large amounts of public money for a system that may or may not be able to do what you need it to do is questionable. From a social standpoint, the idea of anyone with access to the system being to track any imaginable person, group, or activity within the system is a bit frightening. Orwell himself never imagined such a system, although American author David Drake did (in the ”Lacy” stories ). In any case, I have to question the effect this will have on police deployments, invasion of privacy lawsuits, and loss of business from people avoiding the affected parts of town.

The simple fact is, people don’t like being monitored. They are even less fond of spending time in places where the authorities know everything you are doing, and are likely to appear at the drop of anything resembling a suspicious action. And they will sue anyone and everyone involved if they feel any of their rights are being violated, including their right to privacy. If any of this surveillance data falls into the hands of the IRS, for example, or allows one business to gain any advantage over another, the city is in for a huge storm of trouble, and who’s even mentioned the fallout from people who get no response to 911 calls because all available units are busy checking out people who have set down their backpacks?

I’m not objecting to the public scrutiny; I was raised to believe that any time you are in public, you must assume that someone is watching you. And no one will be happier than me if this new system can manage to overcome the vast information overload and actually spot potential hazards on the streets of Chicago. But as a business decision, I’m not sure the city has really thought this one through…

Wednesday, September 26, 2007

Bank Fees and Democracy

I’ve been reading (and watching) a lot of commentary lately about how terrible it is that banks are raising fees, and in particular, the ATM and checking account fees that have the greatest impact on the poorest members of our society. This dovetails with the common perception of bankers as old, rich, white men who don’t care a fig for the public good, and only want to increase their own personal fortunes. Many commentators are even calling for government regulation to prevent this sort of thing.

Well, the fact is, bank fees are rising – you can read the CNN online story about that here if you want to. But the rest of these stories are more rabble-rousing attempts to generate readership (or viewership) than anything relevant, and the calls for government action are preposterous. Certainly, the increased checking account fees would be harder for someone making less money to afford, and someone working a low-income job would be less able to come up with the minimum balance to have their monthly fees waived by the bank. Lower-income customers would also have a harder time affording the fees charged to use an ATM from a bank other than your own. The point is, there is no need for anyone to put up with either class of fees.

In a free market economy, finding a way to eliminate expenses paid by a customer is just as effective as selling products at a lower price – and often easier to market, as it can improve the company’s image for literally no effort at all. In the case of bank fees, many smaller institutions have noted the consumer discontent with these charges and started offering “free” accounts, in order to draw more customers and increase the assets they have on deposit. This has enabled many smaller corporations to compete successfully in markets where they should by rights be out of their league, as well as forcing larger institutions to become more customer-friendly – or risk becoming much smaller companies as a consequence.

In any market where a type of fees are considered standard, the one company that does not charge them will gain a huge competitive advantage over the rest. Government regulation of this sort of problem is unnecessary, as customers will simply “vote with their feet” – taking their business to the competition. With the rise of credit unions and online banking companies, traditional banks can not afford to maintain the “take it or leave it” attitude they are (incorrectly) famous for, and any bank that behaved like the ones in the Washington Mutual commercials (charging people – by the word! – for speaking with a teller) would be lucky to have ANY customers within a week.

Like the atomic fixation of the post WWII era (nuclear power was going to solve everything from communism to bad posture), consumers today seem to fly off the handle and demand government regulation to solve every issue that disturbs them. Fortunately, there is a lot of good data on government-controlled economic systems over the past 100 years. All things considered, I’d rather have bank fees…

Tuesday, September 25, 2007

Says Who?

An interesting sub-point in the ongoing Sub-Prime Lending crisis came up the other day: several different groups are blaming the credit rating agencies for giving their blessing to companies whose participation in sub-prime mortgage transactions led directly to the developing crisis. The rating companies are, in turn, saying that they never told anyone that their ratings were a guarantee of success, or failure, or anything else, and that people are free to ignore them. You can read the CNN story about it here until they take it down. Congress is apparently looking into it, with executives from Moody’s and Standard and Poor’s due to be questioned on Wednesday of this week.

Now, it’s certainly true that Moody’s and S & P have a very large influence in the world of commerce; they are the ones who issue the ratings commonly used for bond issues, which has an enormous impact on the world of debt financing. If you’re not familiar with the terms, debt financing refers to any company raising money by borrowing it (as opposed to selling partial interest in the company, usually through shares of stock, which is called equity financing). Some of this involves bank loans, and some of it involves the issue of bonds, which are essentially the company’s IOUs to anyone willing to lend them the money, but in either case, a company’s rating controls the amount they have to pay to get the money (what interest the bank will charge them for a loan or how much interest they have to pay the private investors on the bond issue).

Naturally, the bond market is extremely complicated, with all sorts of different offers and potentials ways to make (and lose) money. In theory, anyone with a financial calculator and a few weeks of business school training (or the equivalent) should be able to determine a corporation’s book value, and based on that and its income, how likely that company is to be able to pay back a loan. The person making the calculations then adds an appropriate amount to the Prime Rate to compensate for how much less likely the company is to repay the loan as opposed to the Federal government. All of these are standard factors, available to anyone who really wants to look them up.

The point is that most people don’t want to look them up, or spend the time calculating the risk factors to determine if a company is taking on too much debt or is too unlikely to ever pay it back. These calculations aren’t beyond the abilities of anyone who ever passed algebra, but they are time consuming and there are thousands of bond offers available at any given moment. So many people turn to the Moody’s or S & P index to get the current ratings of companies they might want to invest in. Here’s what Standard & Poor’s says about their global index, for example. A high ranking on this system tells investors that it’s relatively safe to lend money to the company in question; a low ranking means you are much more likely to lose your money. The very lowest ranks are sometimes called “Junk Bonds” and are often regarded as being nothing more than a more reputable form of buying lottery tickets.

None of this would be much of a scandal by itself, but now several groups are claiming that the rating agencies were paid off to issue higher ratings to sub-prime lenders than those institutions really deserved, and they’re calling on Congress to pass laws requiring the SEC to start overseeing those ratings. It’s doubtful that much can be done about these companies – they all issue the proper legal disclaimers before they make any ratings, and any finance professional knows that these rankings are made by people working for a for-profit research service, not handed down from on high. Even more to the point, a company whose total profits are only $10 million per year has no reasonable chance of paying back $12 million in interest payments each year, and no high-priced rating firm is necessary to figure that out. Congress can’t pass a law requiring people to stop being greedy, gullible, or foolish with their money.

What all of this does mean is that investors are going to have to start paying more attention to the actual financial health of the companies whose bonds they buy, and not just taking the bond ratings as gospel. So the next time somebody tells you that a given company is a “can’t miss” investment, you might want to reply, “Says who?”…